Featured answer
| Minimum payments can keep you in debt for years because most of the payment may go toward interest instead of reducing the original balance. When the balance stays high and new charges are added, the debt can feel almost impossible to pay down without a stronger repayment plan or a formal debt solution. |
Why minimum payments feel manageable at first
When money is tight, making the minimum payment can feel like the responsible thing to do. It keeps the account from being reported as missed and it can help you avoid immediate collection action. The problem is that a minimum payment is designed to keep the account active, not necessarily to get you out of debt quickly.
Credit card debt is usually revolving debt. That means you can borrow, repay and borrow again up to your credit limit. As you pay down the balance, credit becomes available again. This can be useful in an emergency, but it can also make it very hard to escape debt when the balance is already high.
The real issue is interest
The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada explains that minimum payments are usually based on a flat amount plus interest and fees, or a percentage of the outstanding balance. If your balance is large, your payment may feel significant, but a large part of it can still be going toward interest. See the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada page on paying off your credit card.
For example, someone may pay hundreds of dollars each month and still see the balance move very little. This is especially frustrating when they are also using the card to cover groceries, gas, insurance or other living costs. You can compare payment scenarios using the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada Credit Card Payment Calculator.
Why the balance does not seem to move
There are usually four reasons minimum payments keep people stuck:
- Interest keeps adding to the balance every month.
- The minimum payment shrinks as the balance slowly drops.
- New purchases increase the balance again.
- Multiple cards create multiple minimum payments at once.
This can turn debt into a cycle. You pay what you can, free up a little credit, then use that credit again because there is not enough cash left for the month. For more on understanding debt, see the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada page on understanding debt.
Minimum payments can hide the real problem
Minimum payments can make debt look affordable because each individual payment may seem small. The trouble is the total monthly debt load. One card payment may be manageable. Three credit cards, a line of credit, a payday loan and a tax balance may not be.
A good way to measure the problem is to ask three questions:
- Are you paying more than the minimum?
- Is your total debt going down every month?
- Can you pay your living costs without using more credit?
If the answer is no, the issue may not be discipline. The issue may be that the repayment structure is no longer realistic.
When minimum payments become a warning sign
Minimum payments are a warning sign when they leave you with no room for rent, mortgage payments, utilities, food or transportation. They are also a warning sign when you are using one credit account to pay another.
You may need to review your options if you are experiencing collection calls, missed payments, payday loans, overdraft use, stress about opening bills, or a feeling that your income disappears as soon as you get paid.
What can help
There are several ways to move beyond minimum payments.
A budget can help if the debt is still manageable and you have enough income to make larger payments. A debt consolidation loan can help if you qualify for a lower interest rate and do not continue using the paid-off credit cards. Credit counselling or a debt management plan may help if you can repay the full amount but need structure.
If the debt is too high to repay in full, a consumer proposal may be an option. A consumer proposal is a legal process administered by a Licensed Insolvency Trustee. It can reduce unsecured debt, stop interest and combine payments into one monthly amount. Bankruptcy may be an option when repayment is no longer realistic. Explore the full range of debt relief options.
The main takeaway
Minimum payments are not always bad, but they are rarely a long-term debt solution. If you are making the payments and the balance is not falling, it may be time to get advice before the debt grows further.
Frequently asked questions
Is it bad to only make the minimum payment?
It is better than missing a payment, but it may keep you in debt much longer and cost more in interest.
Why does my credit card balance barely go down?
Interest, fees and new purchases can offset much of the payment, especially if you are only paying the minimum.
When should I ask for help?
Ask for help when your balances are not going down, you are using credit for basic expenses, or you cannot keep up with multiple payments.
Speak with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee
Speak with David Sklar & Associates for a confidential review of your debt, income, assets and monthly budget. A Licensed Insolvency Trustee can explain your options and help you choose a realistic next step. Book a free consultation today.
